Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King (2003).
Episode 50 (!!) and the final episode in the trilogy of Lord of the Rings films. Paul loves scenes where dialogue gets cut off, Jimmy forgets what podcast he's on, Tom and Glen cry a lot, all of them go on a huge quote roll about half-way in, and more in this episode!
Youtube: Meta'd on Youtube
Intro/Outro Tunes: John Kim